Tweet this page!

Thread Reader is happy to present
an unrolled Twitter story with 21 tweets


I'm seeing more and more people make the assertion that "all white people are racist". Is this a good assertion to make?
2/On one hand, you can certainly define the word "racism" in such a way as to make the statement correct.
3/For example, suppose you say that "racism" means benefiting from a system that has oppressed black people. Well, then yeah.
4/If you define "racism" that way, then since all white people have the option of benefiting from that system, all white people are racist.
5/However, is this practical? Is this useful? I worry that this definition of "racist" is highly counterproductive.
6/Most human beings are pretty good people. Therefore, most white people are pretty good people.
7/If all white people are "racist", then that means you can be "racist" and still be a wonderful person.
8/Do we want a definition of "racist" that allows you to be a great person and still be a racist? That carries no individual sanction?
9/If "racist" just becomes a word for "white", then every white person will just shrug and say "Yep, sure I'm a racist, look at my skin!".
10/The moral power of the word "racist" came from its power to shame people over their individual actions. Should we give up that power?
11/I don't agree with everything in this Federalist article, but I think it gets at the issue I'm talking about: http://thefederalist.com/2016/11/14/election-marks-end-americas-racial-detente/
12/More broadly, this issue gets at a problem I've been worrying about recently: the loss of the Left's moral power in America.
13/In the 1990s and 2000s, the American left gained substantial moral authority, and used it to move society in progressive directions.
14/Marriage equality was an example of this. In fact, this moral power is still strong - see companies' response to Charlottesville.
15/The Left's moral power can be used to do many good things - push companies and universities to try to be more diverse, for example.
16/But I worry that this moral power can be weakened through over-application. A bit like antibiotics.
17/If all white people get used to being morally condemned, all the time, just for being who they are, they'll just learn to live with it.
18/Same with all men, all straight people, all cis people, or whatever. Eventually being condemned just becomes a reason to shrug.
19/And if the Left loses its moral power, I fear for this country. I fear a Right unshackled by fear of moral condemnation.
20/Because if moral power goes away, only physical power remains.

And the Right has all of the physical power. http://noahpinionblog.blogspot.com/2016/11/you-and-whose-army.html
21/Therefore, for the good of the country's most vulnerable, I recommend that we of the Left be more judicious in our condemnations. (end)

More from @Noahpinion (see all)
 

Related: